Sunday, October 24, 2021
Home Politics Health Zuma's bid to have his conviction rescinded crashes in ConCourt

Zuma’s bid to have his conviction rescinded crashes in ConCourt

Entertaining application would be permitting appellant to blow hot and cold – justice Khampepe

Former president Jacob Zuma’s last chance to have the ruling ordering his imprisonment rescinded was dealt a blow on Friday after the Constitutional Court dismissed his application.

Delivering the judgment, justice Sisi Khampepe said entertaining Zuma’s application would be equal to permitting him to “blow hot or cold”, as he had deliberately refused to participate in the litigation that resulted in him being jailed.

In June, the apex court sentenced Zuma to 15 months behind bars for contempt of court relating to its order that he complies with the directives of the Zondo commission what he was required to answer to allegations of state capture.

Zuma had refused to attend the commission as he accused its chairperson, acting chief justice Raymond Zondo, of bias and called for his recusal.

Zuma had also refused to participate in the court proceedings initiated by the commission before the apex court as he also accused judges of being politically biased against him.

With no prospects of appealing the conviction, Zuma challenged his conviction through a rescission application.

Rule 42 of the uniform rules of court states that a court may “rescind or vary an order or judgment erroneously sought or erroneously granted in the absence of any party affected thereby or an order or judgment granted as the result of a mistake common to the parties”.

Khampepe said the majority for the ConCourt justices had ruled that Zuma’s rescission application be dismissed with costs.

“It would fly in the face of the interest of justice for a party to be allowed to willfully refuse to participate in litigation and then expect the opportunity to reopen the case when it suits them. It is simply not in the interest of justice to tolerate this manner of litigious vacillation,” Kampepe said.

 Zuma’s legal counsel has argued that the ConCourt had violated his constitutional rights by not first affording him the chance to mitigate his sentence before it slapped him with direct imprisonment.

Zuma’s lawyer, advocate Dali Mpofu SC had told the apex court that it had exceeded the bounds of the Constitution by slapping him with direct imprisonment without a formal trial in lower courts where he would have had an opportunity to appeal.

Mpofu also pointed out that Zuma was very old and sick to be thrown into jail.

This was however refuted by the commission’s counsel, which argued that Zuma had squandered repeated opportunities to mitigate his sanction as he had chosen to abandon all court proceedings and instead to publicly attack the commission and the ConCourt.

The commission’s lawyer, advocate Tembeka Ngcukaitobi SC, counter argued that Zuma had known about his age and medical condition but that he had deliberately “reconciled himself with the possibility of imprisonment”.

Khampepe said there had been no new information brought by Zuma which warranted for the rescission of the judgment against him.

“Although there may be circumstances in which the interest of justice requires rescission, those circumstances must be exceptional to justify a departure from the doctrine. There is nothing in Mr Zuma’s case that can be construed as truly exceptional to the extent that the court should depart from the underlying principle and ordinary tenets of the rule of law,” she said.

Khampepe said the court had emphasised that the importance of protecting the principle of finality in litigation.

“It is precisely to protect this principle, that the orders of the ConCourt are immune from appeal,” she said.

RELATED ARTICLES

Equal Education protesters denounce ANC at Ramaphosa’s Khayelitsha rally

Members of lobby group Equal Education on Thursday infiltrated an ANC election rally in Khayelitsha on the Cape Flats, where party president...

SA accuses Zim of ‘killing’ Africa trade through Beitbridge truck delays

HARARE – South Africa has accused Zimbabwe of “killing business” over border delays for haulage trucks at Beitbridge. Queues...

Former USA President Trump to launch his own twitter App to rival Zuckerberg ‘social media apps

Former USA President Donald Trump to launch his own social media app. The ex-US President says he will launch the app TRUTH...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Here’s what the ANC intends to ask its mayoral candidates

Prospective ANC mayors will have to field at least 18 tough questions from a panel of interviewers on why they should be...

Mbeki calls for a painful ANC renewal

Former president Thabo Mbeki was sitting at home one day when he got a missed call from a Cape Town phone number....

Horror man beats wife to coma for denying him s.e.x

Horror man beats wife to coma for denying him s.e.x. While a woman fights for her life in the intensive care unit,...

Zimbabweans criticised for taking SA Govt to court over exemption permits

Some Zimbabwean nationals based in South Africa have criticised their compatriots who recently took that government to...

Recent Comments